Page 2 of 2

Re: CAF's Africa Best XI for 2018 - 7 Premier League player

Posted: Wed Jan 09, 2019 4:43 pm
by Rawlings
ohenhen1 wrote:Ndidi is better than Partey.
Troost Ekong should be in the squad ahead of Bailly. Bailly that is not even a regular for Man United is ahead of Ekong who played well for Nigeria at the World cup, world cup qualifiers and he is playing well for Udinese.
Ndidi is better than Partey on CE :winking:
The neutrals think otherwise
One plays for a middle of the road EPL team
The other plays for one of the top teams in Europe's best league
One is valued more than the other (viewtopic.php?f=1&t=292852)

Go Figure!!!

Re: CAF's Africa Best XI for 2018 - 7 Premier League player

Posted: Wed Jan 09, 2019 4:44 pm
by wale1974
maceo4 wrote:
balo wrote:Baily made the list. That's all you need to know it's rubbish.
Isn’t it based on last season...
Aurier, Baily, and Keita spent more time on the bench and Doctor's bed.................Good players but not at the expensive of Ndidi, Colley and Mazraoui

Re: CAF's Africa Best XI for 2018 - 7 Premier League player

Posted: Wed Jan 09, 2019 4:44 pm
by tfco
Odas wrote:
tfco wrote:
EMIR KONGI JAFFI JOFFA wrote:
The real deal wrote:Super stars I suppose
How come Africa performed so bad @ the WC If EPL IS so great?
I don't know how the English gets into you guys skull so much!
Colonial mentality
Nkrumah must be crying blood seeing this post
It's ridiculous. The union jackers have killed SE, gone are the days when almost each one of our best players had a thread on CE. It's all Arsenal, Man U and Chelsea. Boring.
has anyone on the forum prevented you guys from creating threads on 'our best players'?
TFCO, why are you being "sneaky?" Why didn't you write out the word "your" in your post instead of hiding your intention(s)?
you're welcome

Re: CAF's Africa Best XI for 2018 - 7 Premier League player

Posted: Wed Jan 09, 2019 5:26 pm
by wale1974
Rawlings wrote:
ohenhen1 wrote:Ndidi is better than Partey.
Troost Ekong should be in the squad ahead of Bailly. Bailly that is not even a regular for Man United is ahead of Ekong who played well for Nigeria at the World cup, world cup qualifiers and he is playing well for Udinese.
Ndidi is better than Partey on CE :winking:
The neutrals think otherwise
One plays for a middle of the road EPL team
The other plays for one of the top teams in Europe's best league
One is valued more than the other (viewtopic.php?f=1&t=292852)

Go Figure!!!
https://www.whoscored.com/PlayerComparison

Compare both players here.

Re: CAF's Africa Best XI for 2018 - 7 Premier League player

Posted: Wed Jan 09, 2019 6:16 pm
by olu
It depends on what you're looking for. If you want a destroyer or pure DM then Ndidi is better for that role than Partey. However if your team needs a two way box to box midfielder that can join the attack and protect the defense then I will go with Partey. Partey is the more complete player so I see why he was picked ahead of Ndidi. I would have left out Keita and picked Ndidi because Keita missed a good number of games last year.
ohenhen1 wrote:Ndidi is better than Partey.


Troost Ekong should be in the squad ahead of Bailly. Bailly that is not even a regular for Man United is ahead of Ekong who played well for Nigeria at the World cup, world cup qualifiers and he is playing well for Udinese.

Re: CAF's Africa Best XI for 2018 - 7 Premier League player

Posted: Wed Jan 09, 2019 6:20 pm
by Rawlings
wale1974 wrote:
Rawlings wrote:
ohenhen1 wrote:Ndidi is better than Partey.
Troost Ekong should be in the squad ahead of Bailly. Bailly that is not even a regular for Man United is ahead of Ekong who played well for Nigeria at the World cup, world cup qualifiers and he is playing well for Udinese.
Ndidi is better than Partey on CE :winking:
The neutrals think otherwise
One plays for a middle of the road EPL team
The other plays for one of the top teams in Europe's best league
One is valued more than the other (viewtopic.php?f=1&t=292852)
Go Figure!!!
https://www.whoscored.com/PlayerComparison
Compare both players here.
Can I also compare Kojo Owusu(Kotoko, Ghana) vs Ndidi(Leicester, EPL)?
My Point:
  • One plays for a top club in the worlds best league
    The league that has won 5 of the last 5 Champions league
    Guess which one?

Re: CAF's Africa Best XI for 2018 - 7 Premier League player

Posted: Wed Jan 09, 2019 6:20 pm
by imehjunior
Ndidi and Musa for Mahrez

Re: CAF's Africa Best XI for 2018 - 7 Premier League player

Posted: Wed Jan 09, 2019 7:10 pm
by Rawlings
imehjunior wrote:Ndidi and Musa for Mahrez
Iheanacho for _____ ?
Mikel Obi for _____?
Success for Failure :)

Re: CAF's Africa Best XI for 2018 - 7 Premier League player

Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2019 3:59 am
by Bigpokey24
Ok after analyzing the list , there is a massive error by CAF . Ndidi needs to be the first name in that Midfield..chei
..nah real wah for CAF

Re: CAF's Africa Best XI for 2018 - 7 Premier League player

Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2019 4:54 pm
by wiseone
What on earth are the Ivorians Bailly and Aurier (two reserves) doing in there? Worse still, they put Koulibaly at LB so they could fit in those two! :shock: The two CDs should have been Benatia and Koulibaly - end of. Plus where is Hakimi (of Real Madrid AND Dortmund!). Onyango instead of the young Ajax GK Onana? ... hmm...

Re: CAF's Africa Best XI for 2018 - 7 Premier League player

Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2019 5:37 pm
by King Futcha
Bigpokey24 wrote:Ok after analyzing the list , there is a massive error by CAF . Ndidi needs to be the first name in that Midfield..chei
..nah real wah for CAF
Ndidi is the goods but he is not better than Thomas its a Partey or Keita (before Liverpool ruined him)

Re: CAF's Africa Best XI for 2018 - 7 Premier League player

Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2019 7:28 pm
by Rawlings
King Futcha wrote:
Bigpokey24 wrote:Ok after analyzing the list , there is a massive error by CAF . Ndidi needs to be the first name in that Midfield..chei
..nah real wah for CAF
Ndidi is the goods but he is not better than Thomas its a Partey or Keita (before Liverpool ruined him)
Besides, Partey plays for one of the top 3 teams in the best league in the world :winking:
Ndidi plays for a middle of the road EPL side

Re: CAF's Africa Best XI for 2018 - 7 Premier League player

Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2019 8:12 pm
by tfco
Rawlings wrote:This was CAF's line up (not mine) :winking:

Image
none from the GoA

no wonder they're all triggered

Re: CAF's Africa Best XI for 2018 - 7 Premier League player

Posted: Fri Jan 11, 2019 9:12 pm
by john12
The list is 100 percent correct and this is why I keep emphasizing that we encourage our players to sign for world class clubs so they can get accustomed to world class awards and world class players. You cannot think that average/backwater clubs will get precedence over World class teams.
Ndidi plays at Leicester (no award last year)
Partey plays at Atletico (Europa league champions ) the competition Partey faces is way higher than ndidi level and he would probably be a star man at a small club. Anyway, I expect ndidi to make a move to one of the best clubs next season if he is good as you guys claim

Re: CAF's Africa Best XI for 2018 - 7 Premier League player

Posted: Sat Jan 12, 2019 6:23 am
by Rawlings
UEFA Team of the Year 2018: Ter Stegen; Ramos, Van Dijk; Marcelo, Modric, Kante, Hazard; Mbappe, Messi, Ronaldo